Your organisation looks strong, growth is steady, financials are solid, and no major red flags are visible. But beneath the surface, is your company thriving, or just masking deeper vulnerabilities?

This is the Watermelon Effect, a business that appears green and healthy on the outside but is red and decaying at its core. It’s a silent risk, one that has blindsided companies that once seemed untouchable.

The numbers tell a concerning story:

- 46% of employees don’t report workplace issues due to fear or the belief that nothing will change. (Syntrio)

- Microsoft recently cut 2,000 employees as part of an effort to eliminate complacency and reinforce a performance-driven culture. (Business Insider)

A company that ignores or suppresses real challenges is one that will eventually be caught off guard. The question isn’t whether you have hidden risks, it’s whether you’re willing to face them.

Break One Rule: Stability Doesn’t Come from Silence

For too long, leaders have assumed that if no one is raising concerns, everything must be running smoothly. This belief is not just outdated, it’s dangerous.

Silence is rarely a sign of stability. It’s often a symptom of fear, disengagement, or apathy. Employees who believe speaking up won’t change anything, or worse, that it will backfire, simply stop trying.

A study by Syntrio found that 46% of employees do not report workplace issues, primarily due to fear of retaliation or skepticism about leadership’s willingness to act.

Leaders who rely on surface-level alignment are often the last to realise when their company is heading towards crisis.

What to do instead:

• Treat silence as a risk indicator rather than a sign of alignment.
• Build mechanisms for real feedback—not just surveys, but direct, unfiltered conversations.
• Encourage constructive dissent—the best ideas often emerge from challenging discussions.

Build One Bold Idea: Transparency as a Leadership Strategy

High-performing organisations don’t just welcome difficult conversations, they engineer them into their culture.

Consider Microsoft. The tech giant recently cut 2,000 employees in a move to remove complacency and reinforce performance expectations.

The shift wasn’t just about numbers. It was about resetting cultural expectations, ensuring that success wasn’t just about tenure or comfort but about real contribution.

The most resilient organisations don’t just react to crises, they make difficult decisions before they become unavoidable.

What to do instead:

• Create a culture of visibility—leaders should be transparent about both wins and challenges.
• Build real-time feedback loops—not just annual reviews, but continuous, honest discussions.
• Reward truth-telling, not compliance—employees should be valued for raising difficult but necessary issues.

Burn One Bridge: The Fear of Hard Conversations Must Go

Nothing erodes an organisation faster than a leadership culture where bad news is ignored, punished, or avoided.

Take Volkswagen. Employees knew that the company’s diesel engines were rigged to cheat emissions tests, but the culture discouraged questioning leadership. The result? A global scandal that cost $35 billion in lawsuits, fines, and reputational damage.

The fear of surfacing hard truths is what destroys businesses, not the truths themselves.

What to do instead:

• Replace hierarchical reporting with candid dialogue—the best leaders are those who invite scrutiny.
• Normalise escalating problems early—bad news should travel faster than good news.
• Build a culture where leaders are questioned—if no one is challenging assumptions, you have a problem.

Success That Lasts Comes from Truth, Not Optics

The Watermelon Effect is real, and it’s not just about failing companies, it happens in the best companies that get too comfortable.

The leaders who succeed are those who break the silence-stability myth, build transparency into their leadership strategy, and burn the fear of uncomfortable truths.

Your business might look strong today, but what’s happening beneath the surface? More importantly, do you have the courage to find out?

Hi, I am Margo...
I'm the trusted advisor executives turn to when they're ready to deep dive into what's really working, and what's not.

At your level, you don't vent to peers; I support you to reflect clearly, adjust effectively, and sharpen your edge, so you can disrupt norms, drive change, and build a lasting legacy that balances professional ambition with personal growth.

I'm offering a strictly limited number of exclusive, 45-minute Laser-Focused Coaching Sessions, designed specifically for executives who are ready to elevate their leadership and sharpen their competitive edge. These high-impact sessions are available for those committed to driving real transformation.​